By Sam Ellis, a Create Wellbeing pen name.
You pick up the guitar because you fancy playing that song you used to love. Then you remember the exercise you’re supposed to practise. Out comes the metronome. Someone on the internet can play it faster. Twenty minutes later you’ve put the guitar down without playing the song.
How did the thing you chose to do in your spare time end up sounding so much like another job?
What are you measuring these days?
Wanting to improve can be a lovely part of a hobby. It’s satisfying to hear a chord change come out cleanly or to see the light in a photo exactly as you pictured it. A target can give you a reason to pick something up on a day when you might otherwise walk past it.
It’s worth noticing when the target starts deciding what counts. If you only had ten minutes to play, did those minutes count? If you went for a walk and left your watch on the charger, does the outing somehow feel less real? Nobody took the walk away. The record of it just looks different.
In a series of experiments, researcher Jordan Etkin found that measuring an activity could increase how much people did while also reducing their enjoyment of it. Activities such as walking and reading could start to feel more like work when people focused on their output. Those findings are a useful question to put to your own hobby. How does keeping score affect the part of it you actually like?
Remember what got your attention in the first place
Maybe you picked up a camera because of the colour the sea goes just before a storm. Now every photo has to be good enough to post. Perhaps you liked drawing ridiculous dogs on birthday cards. Then you bought a sketchbook so nice you feel reluctant to spoil a page.
Try finishing this thought. “The bit I would still do if nobody saw it is…” Take your first answer seriously. It might be finding the right sound on a guitar pedal, sketching the dog while she sleeps or walking to the water to see what colour it is today. That gives you a small part of the hobby you can revisit.
Give one session a different job
If you enjoy practising, keep practising. Just try one session where the arrangements are different. Leave the tempo unrecorded, choose a song you already know and play it as slowly or as badly as you like. If you find yourself reaching for the metronome, ask what you want from the next ten minutes. Sometimes the answer really is to nail that tricky change. Other times you’d quite like to sing the chorus.
Afterwards, ask what held your interest. Perhaps you played for longer. Perhaps you stopped after one song and went on with your day. Either answer gives you information about how you want to spend your free time.
Next time you pick up the guitar, there’s a simple experiment waiting. Play the song that made you pick it up, at least once, before you start the exercise.
