← Back to the blog

CREATE WELLBEING / THE BLOG

I said no. Why do I still feel guilty?

Someone holds their shoes at the door. Slippers and a sleeping dog wait in the warm living room.

By Alex Rowan, a Create Wellbeing pen name.

Someone asks you to dinner on Saturday. You like them. You’d normally enjoy catching up. But this week has been a lot, and what you really want is an evening at home with the dog and something you can eat out of a bowl.

So you say no. Nicely. Ten minutes later you’re looking at your phone again. Did that sound rude? Should I explain how tired I am? What if they stop asking? You start typing another message. Part of you is thinking about going after all, just so you can stop feeling guilty.

What agreement did you actually make?

Before you change your answer, think about what you actually agreed to. If you promised a mate a lift and cancelled at the last minute, they now have to find another way there. A phone call, an apology or some help finding another lift might make a difference.

If you hadn’t said yes to dinner, try asking yourself, Have I broken a promise, or am I worried about how my answer will feel to them? You might feel guilty because you care about them, or because saying yes usually feels easier. Give yourself a minute before you send that second message.

And yes, they might be disappointed. Asking you along might have been their way of saying, “I’d like to spend time with you.” Tonight, though, you don’t have much left to give. You can care about their disappointment and still stay home.

You can give a warm answer in one sentence

Researchers Julian Givi and Colleen Kirk found that people who turned down social invitations often expected a worse reaction than the person inviting them reported. The exchange you’re replaying might feel quite different at the other end of the phone. The studies were about ordinary invitations. The history between you and your friend still matters.

“Thanks for asking me. I’m going to sit this one out, but I hope you have a good night.” That tells them what they need to know and lets them know you appreciate being asked. If you’d like to catch up another time, you could add, “Would you be up for a walk on Sunday morning?” Offer a plan you actually want to keep.

Give your first answer a chance

If you’re about to send a longer explanation, read the first message as though a mate sent it to you. Would you hear, They don’t want to see me anymore, or Fair enough. We’ll catch up another time? If you’ve answered kindly and clearly, try putting the phone down for a while.

It’s also worth noticing how the night in feels. Do you settle in and enjoy it, or have you been saying no to everything and then wishing you had company? If you want to see people but a whole evening feels too much, suggest something smaller: a coffee, a short walk or dropping in for an hour.

For this Saturday, a quiet night might be exactly what you want. Put your slippers on. Sit with the dog. You might still feel guilty for a bit. You don’t have to pick the phone back up.

Source

Givi, J., & Kirk, C. P. (2024). Saying no: The negative ramifications from invitation declines are less severe than we think. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 126(6), 1103–1115.