← Back to the blog

CREATE WELLBEING / THE BLOG

I’m telling you how I feel. Why are you trying to fix it?

Two people sit at a kitchen table with mugs, one talking while the other listens.

Two people can be having entirely different conversations

You get home after a difficult day. Before you’ve even reached the part that really upset you, the suggestions have already started.

“Send an email.” “Speak to your manager.” “Try not to worry about it.” “Just let it go.”

You stop talking. Somehow you feel a little more alone than you did before you brought it up. The other person is left wondering, Why did you come to me if you didn’t want my help?

One person was saying, “Please understand what this was like for me.” The other heard, “Please tell me what to do.” Both people can care about each other and still miss what was needed in that moment.

It happens between partners, friends, and parents and their adult children. People offer support in ways they’ve learnt to offer it, and what we need can change from one day to the next. Today, you might want someone to hear you out. Tomorrow, you might ask that same person to help you write the email.

Why advice can land badly, even when it makes sense

Maybe you already know how to reply to the email. What hurt was that they made the decision without asking you. Again. And you’re tired of feeling like what you have to say doesn’t count.

When the conversation moves straight to the next task, what you hear might be, This is easy. Why are you so upset? That may be the last thing the other person meant to say. It can still be how it lands.

If you’re the one offering solutions, it can be hard to watch someone you love struggle. You might be thinking, I wish I could take this away from you. Or, if you’re honest with yourself, I don’t really know what to do when you’re hurting, and giving you something practical feels better than sitting here not knowing. Maybe doing something useful is how you learnt to show you care.

Research on couples talking through stressful experiences found that attentive listening was linked with more helpful support (Kuhn et al., 2018). You don’t have to turn every conversation into a long debrief. Sometimes the helpful thing is simply to stay with the person long enough to hear the part they came to tell you.

So how do we handle this?

If you’re sharing, give them a bit of a blueprint. “Could you just listen for a couple of minutes? I’m not looking for advice yet.” Or, “I do want help deciding what to do, but first I need to tell you why it bothered me.”

We often assume the people who know us best should know what we need. But they might be reaching for what they’d want. Saying it out loud takes away some of the guesswork.

If you’re listening, give them time to finish the thought. Put down what you’re doing if you can. Try, “It sounds like you felt dismissed when they made that decision without you. Have I got that right?” You can acknowledge the hurt without deciding what the other person meant. Sometimes “I can see why that stung” or “What was the hardest part?” is enough. Give yourself time to hear the answer before offering advice.

There’s still a place for solving the problem

Once you’ve listened, ask what would help next. “Do you want to think through some options, or would you rather I sit with you for a bit?” It’s okay to be a little awkward: “I’m not sure what you need from me right now. What would help?”

The answer might be, “Could you get dinner started?” or “No, I just needed to say it out loud.” If they want ideas, try offering one without taking over: “Would it help to ask for a follow-up meeting? What do you reckon?” They’re still the one who has to walk into that room. Feeling understood, validated and cared for matters in close relationships (Arican-Dinc & Gable, 2023).

If you can’t listen properly right now, say when you can. “I want to hear this properly. Can we sit down after dinner?” Then come back after dinner. If you keep getting stuck on the same issue, you might need a clearer request, a practical change, or some help from outside the relationship.

Talking can help without being the only thing that needs to change.

Make room for repair

If you catch yourself “fixing” too quickly, you can go back: “I jumped into advice. What did you need me to hear?” And if you’re the one sharing: “I know you’re trying to help. I need you to understand this part first.” There’s that blueprint again. You’re giving the other person a way back into the conversation.

Know when safety comes first

This assumes it’s safe enough to speak honestly. If someone repeatedly intimidates you, threatens you, controls you or punishes you for saying how you feel, that’s not a listening problem. Prioritise your safety and seek individual, specialist support. It isn’t on you to find the perfect words.

For the ordinary times when you’re simply missing each other, try this: “That sounds hard. What happened then?”

Let them finish the story. You can work out what to do next together, if there’s anything that needs doing at all.

References

Arican-Dinc, B., & Gable, S. L. (2023). Responsiveness in romantic partners’ interactions. Current Opinion in Psychology, 53, Article 101652. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.copsyc.2023.101652

Kuhn, R., Bradbury, T. N., Nussbeck, F. W., & Bodenmann, G. (2018). The power of listening: Lending an ear to the partner during dyadic coping conversations. Journal of Family Psychology, 32(6), 762–772. https://doi.org/10.1037/fam0000421